Mathematics Education

Amy SanFrotello

Director, Learning Research

Simple Task, Big Thinking

Published

Last updated

Everyday Opportunities for Math Practices  

In our last article, we explored how teacher noticing unlocks the mathematical potential within any task. As students worked together to solve a real-world application problem, we saw the value of meeting students where they are and using their current thinking as a starting point for engaging with the Standards for Mathematical Practice. In this article, we'll see how even the simplest of tasks can spark rich mathematical reasoning and discourse, enabling students to engage in SMP.3 and SMP.6 as they work together on the task. Through teacher noticing, educators can build on students' thinking, using what they already understand to guide them toward their next steps in mathematical learning.  

What Are the Mathematical Practices? 

As a reminder, the Standards for Mathematical Practice¹ describe eight habits of mind evidenced in mathematically proficient students as they engage deeply with mathematics.  

Standards for Mathematical Practice (SMP)

  1. Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them.

  2. Reason abstractly and quantitatively.

  3. Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others.

  4. Model with mathematics.

  5. Use appropriate tools strategically.

  6. Attend to precision.

  7. Look for and make use of structure.

  8. Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning.

In contrast to the Content Standards which represent what students are to learn, these Standards for Mathematical Practice embody the how – those behaviors and habits of mind that mathematically proficient students should experience as they are learning and doing mathematics. To illustrate, let’s explore a vignette from a third-grade classroom. 


Making Sense of Multiplication: A Grade 3 Task 

Miss Coral’s third grade class has been developing an understanding of multiplication through multiple representations: equal groups, number lines, skip counting, and writing equations. Students are now working in pairs to solve and discuss the following problem. 

Group A: Modeling Number of Groups and Number in Each Group   

Miss Coral notices that Brianna has drawn four groups of six, and Lacie has drawn six groups of four. The partners are trying to decide whether the models represent 4 × 6. 

  • Brianna: "This one is 4 x 6 because there are four groups of six." 

  • Lacie: "But I thought this one could be 4 x 6 because it's six groups of four." 

  • Brianna: "That's 6 x 4, not 4 x 6." 

  • Lacie: "But they both have 24!" 

Miss Coral asks, "Could you both be correct? Why don’t you take turns explaining how your model represents the product. What does the 4 represent in your model? What does the 6 represent?” The students each take turns explaining. Then Miss Coral asks, "Do you think two different models can represent the same multiplication equation? Why or why not? How can you convince your partner?" 

SMP Opportunity: Miss Coral was able to see the opportunity within the student responses and lean into SMP.3 (Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others) in a way that was authentic to the student thinking on the task. SMP.3 was supported by constructing an argument about why the models represent the same product.

Group B: Choosing a Favorite Without Explaining Why 

Kylie and Sam have created two accurate models: an array and four equal groups of six. They complete the equation correctly, but when asked which model they prefer and why, they simply choose the one they like better.

  • Kylie: "I like the groups model better." 

  • Sam: "I like the array." 

  • Kylie: "I think mine is easier." 

  • Sam: "But mine is easier because it shows all the dots together." 

Miss Coral wants to move the students toward using mathematical reasoning to justify their choice. "Can you explain how your model helps you see the four groups of six? What makes your model easier for you to understand?" Kylie and Sam take turns explaining how their model shows the multiplication. Then Miss Coral says, "Did you understand your partner's model? Now take turns explaining how your partner's model helps you to know the answer is 24." 

SMP Opportunity: Miss Coral noticed the partners were not justifying their reasoning with mathematics. She used this as an opportunity to encourage SMP.3 (Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others) by asking them to explain how their model illustrates the mathematics, and then asking them to listen and understand their partner's explanation. SMP.3 was supported by justifying a preference and considering a partner's reasoning. 

Group C: Two Ways to Skip Count 

Peter and Mai Li each used number line paper to show skip counting. Peter drew 6 jumps of 4 and Mai Li drew 4 jumps of 6. Both landed on 24. 

  • Peter: “We solved it two different ways.”  

  • Mai Li: “No we didn’t! We got the same answer.” 

Miss Coral asks, “Have you taken turns explaining to your partner your strategy and how you used it to find the product? Listen to your partner and decide if you agree with their thinking. What labels could you add to each drawing to show how they each represent the multiplication equation?” 

SMP Opportunity: Hearing them focusing mostly on the answer instead of the models, Miss Coral saw an opportunity to encourage SMP.3 (Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others) by asking them to take turns constructing an argument and listening to their partner's reasoning. Noticing that neither student had labeled the jumps, she saw an opportunity for SMP.6 (Attend to precision) and asked them how they could accurately identify and label the factors in their model of the multiplication equation. 

Group D: Explaining How Two Models Are the Same 

James has drawn an array with four rows of six dots, and Benny used number line paper to sketch six jumps of four. They agree that both models show 24, but when asked how they are the same and different, they struggle to explain. 

  • James: "They're different because one is an array and one is a number line." 

  • Benny: "Yeah. I don't see any way they are the same." 

Miss Coral says, "Let's look at the numbers represented in each. In James's model, what can you see in the way the dots are organized? Now look at the number line. What does each jump represent?" James and Benny agree that the array shows 4 rows with 6 dots in each row, and the number line shows 6 jumps of 4. Miss Coral asks, "How are these similar? Could you look at James's array differently to show the multiplication in the same way that Benny's number line shows it?" 

SMP Opportunity: Miss Coral noticed the pair struggling to identify mathematical similarities and differences, so she nudged them toward SMP.6 (Attend to precision) by asking probing questions about the numbers represented in each model. Her questioning encouraged them to use precise mathematical language to describe the rows, columns, jumps, and equal groups in their models.


Ordinary Tasks, Extraordinary Thinking 

Across these vignettes, a common thread emerges: As Miss Coral walks around the room, she continually observes what students are doing and saying, interpreting what those observations reveal about their understanding, and considering where their reasoning is developing or where they may be struggling. Rather than simply checking for correct answers, she uses thoughtful, probing questions to build on students' current thinking and move them toward deeper engagement with the Standards for Mathematical Practice.  

An Important Takeaway 

From the examples in the first two articles of this series, we can start to see that a mathematical task doesn't have to be inherently complex to create opportunities for rich mathematical thinking. Even an ordinary problem can become a springboard for reasoning, justification, precision, and meaningful mathematical discourse when a teacher is intentional about noticing student thinking and using it to guide what happens next. It's not just the task that creates the opportunity for rich mathematics; it's what the teacher notices and does with the thinking that emerges. 

In our next article, we will explore ways to engage students in SMP.4 and SMP.5 as they choose how to model and solve a problem with mathematics. 

References

¹ National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and Council of Chief State School Officers (NGA & CCSSO). (2010). Common Core State Standards for Mathematics. National Governors Association Center for Best Practices, Council of Chief State School Officers, Washington D.C. 

© 2025 Big Ideas Learning

"Big Ideas Learning” and related marks are registered trademarks of Larson Texts, Inc. Big Ideas Learning is a wholly owned subsidiary of Larson Texts, Inc.

© 2025 Big Ideas Learning

"Big Ideas Learning” and related marks are registered trademarks of Larson Texts, Inc. Big Ideas Learning is a wholly owned subsidiary of Larson Texts, Inc.

© 2025 Big Ideas Learning

"Big Ideas Learning” and related marks are registered trademarks of Larson Texts, Inc. Big Ideas Learning is a wholly owned subsidiary of Larson Texts, Inc.